It is said that students can't write anymore, can't use punctuation, can't identify nor write a complex sentence (or worse). In many cases, this is absolutely true. But, let me break it down to an even more basic problem:
Students cannot write legibly anymore. For me, this is the crux of the problem.
When I first started teaching in my current district, all of my students were required to write in pen and in cursive. After a few years, we relaxed that standard. Somewhere along the frameworks-pushed way, handwriting and penmanship gave way in elementary schools to things like social-emotional wellness. By the time the kiddos got to me, they had socialized victim mentality and writing that resembled chicken scratch written in a foreign alphabet system.
So, this year, I have a poster that depicts what the regular printed alphabet looks like, letter by letter, with little arrows teaching the students exactly how to stroke out the letters in pencil or pen. On day one, I announced, "If your letters don't look more like these," and I pointed to the poster, "then you will be rewriting and rewriting and rewriting your work until it does look like this."
I also announced that anyone who masters the printed alphabet is welcome to experiment with the cursive alphabet, of which I also have a poster. Every day I post an inspirational quote on the board, always written in cursive, with the challenge, "Read this, if you can!" It has proven to be a popular activity.
Before you blast me about IEPs and 504s and PT and OT, understand that unless the child is actually physically missing a hand, or has a degenerative hand or arm condition, or a temporary issue such as a brace or cast, or is mentally unable to write, then that child can produce writing that resembles or even emulates the printed letters on the poster. Period.
One boy boasted that he didn't have to follow my directive. My expression clearly stated otherwise. He stood up and said, "Yeah, that's not going to work because I have terrible handwriting."
I gave the child my caring face (hint: I don't have one), and replied, "Oh, pumpkin. That sounds like a you problem, not a me problem. Feel free to have a seat."
I am pleased to report that we are three weeks into the school year, and it has been a very long time since I have been able to clearly decipher (and
grade) the students' work, until now, that is. They seem to understand that illegible handwriting isn't just good practice. It is also brainpower, willpower, and academic power. Being careful writers also helps them to be careful thinkers. It seems that
how they write something directly corresponds with the actual initiative
to write something.
For now, I don't have any scientific data beyond my own observations. I do, however, look forward to practicing cursive with them eventually. There are many studies on the interconnectedness of contiguous writing and contiguous thought. It's kind of like playing Connect the Dots with a captive audience.
Mastering basic writing skills at ages twelve and thirteen really is too late. Unfortunately, the state only allows teachers minimal time and support to work on handwriting skills. I shouldn't have to teach them the basics all over again, but, dagnabbit, I will. If any group can pull it off, it's the group I have now. Maybe then I truly will give them a real caring face, after all.